Faith and reason – let me know what you think

 “Faith is more than my guiding light. It is my kinetic energy.”

  – Helen Keller

 I recently attended an event and panel discussion on Islam. All panelists were people active in movements for human rights.

Something about the panel struck me immediately: there were no women on it who identified as practicing Muslims. In fact, there was only one woman on the panel at all. She certainly had valuable things to say, and I appreciated her perspective.

Unfortunately, though, no effort was made (that I know of) to include the voices of believing women on the panel. While the event was enlightening and positive overall, I couldn’t help but be disappointed by what I felt to be a conspicuous void in the conversation. While the men on the panel represented various levels of belief, there was no diversity when it came to women’s voices.

The implications of situations like these are, I think, grave. The fact of the matter is this: the panel was worthwhile, the sponsoring organization sincere in their mission, and the participants all passionate and intelligent people. However, what is the unspoken message when believing women are excluded from conversations about human rights, reason, and justice within Islam?

I trust you’ll all tell me if I’ve just gotten too caught up in the “politics of representing”. However, to me, the unspoken message – unintentional as it may have been – was that Muslim women aren’t inclined – or outspoken enough – to engage in public dialogues about human rights and our faith. Even when progressive viewpoints are presented, the silencing of the female Muslim voice reinforces the stereotype that women of faith are passive and not engaged with the relevant issues of our time.

I know this stereotype to be false; and I’m almost positive that the panel’s organizers would agree with me.

If it weren’t for my faith, I know I could not maintain my resolve through the trials of daily life. I know the same is true for countless Muslim women.

So, my question is this: how do Muslim women ensure that our voices are front and center in conversations like the one I attended? How do we demand that we are not ignored, even by those who claim to be interested in working for our rights?

“If anyone says, `Why have you included Rabia [often called Islam’s first female saint] in the rank of men?’, my answer is that the Prophet himself said: `God does not regard your outward forms’. The root of the matter is not form, but intention, as the Prophet said.” – Farid-ud-Din Attar, Tazkirat al-Auliya


2 thoughts on “Faith and reason – let me know what you think

  1. I think it is possible to be over sensitive to the issues that are first and foremost on our own minds. For example: the Volkswagen Bug phenomena. It goes something like this – you never notice how many of the old ‘70s model VW Bugs there are still on the road until you take a ride in one. Your personal experience with the vehicle brings them to the front of your awareness and suddenly you see them everywhere. They didn’t suddenly appear. They’re just more noticeable once you’re reminded of them.
    In your case, the “VW Bug” is “gender and faith bias.”
    So the answer to the question: how do Muslim women ensure that our voices are front and center in conversations like the one I attended? How do we demand that we are not ignored, even by those who claim to be interested in working for our rights?
    Is You. YOU were there to represent the very group whom you felt was absent. As long as YOU have a voice, the “Practicing Female Muslim” will always be represented where ever you go. Lead by example and others will follow. Just be prepared for the fallout from those who disagree and work to silence or discredit you. You cannot expect others to step up unless your willing to do so yourself.

  2. You made an excellent point. Once I attended a lecture series and one of the lectures was about ideal women in Islam and all the examples I heard were about mothers, sisters, grandmothers of great men. The whole lecture was about women being secondary in society and never as a primary role.

    I don’t exactly know the answer to your question, but I do think that there is a great importance to one on one conversations. When I entered college, I didn’t have to dance or run around to communicate to people. I find that if Muslims (not just women) take the effort to smile and say hello to someone, that will already cause a form of communication between the two people. And it will break a stereotype that I believe exists about Muslims being very distant or not very friendly. And help spread the innate human love. =)

    Muslim women don’t have to make epic speeches, but by getting involved in the community, speaking to random people on the street and even exchanging a friendly smile can do a world of good.

    But you are the scholar, so you must know a lot more than me!

    Wonderful article!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s